Review of the Movie ‘GMO OMG’

Edited by Peter

It has taken me over a year, but I have finally tracked down a copy of Jeremy Seifert’s 2013 anti-GMO documentary ‘GMO OMG’ and I have to say it was very disappointing.

The movie was very slow and, at times, I did not know if I was watching a documentary about GMOs or some guy’s vacation footage. It’s also extremely padded with the vast majority of the film consisting of Jeremy interviewing farmers and people on the streets about their views on GMOs – most of whom don’t even know what a GMO is, but somehow by the end of the documentary believe they are more than qualified to give their opinion on the subject. I am not exaggerating here – people who, at the beginning of the documentary, did not know what the acronym GMO stood for are, at the end of the movie, telling us that they should be avoided at all costs.

A lot of effort was made in making this movie seem quaint with its overly simplistic bumbling score and family orientated narrative, but it came off as contrived and disingenuous. Jeremy also subscribes to the cliché Michael Moore “I’m a simpleton” style of documentary film making which, on a personal note, I find particularly irritating. This is because I believe when covering “controversial” subjects you have to make the effort to talk to the people who may be able to answer your questions. Randomly turning up at some small Monsanto building, as Jeremy does, hoping to get an interview with a scientist or spokesperson from Monsanto is juvenile and makes the documentary a farce.

GMO OMG 2

The movie was also full of set-ups that had no pay off. For example, he made GMO detection goggles for his sons to wear that made up about five minutes of the documentary which went……absolutely nowhere, he travelled to Norway to visit Svalbard Global Seed Vault which was completely pointless (in fact I don’t think we ever saw any footage of him in the vault, leading me to believe he was denied access), and he made a big song and dance about getting angry with Monsanto but then all he did was walk into some random Monsanto building as I said above for all of 5 minutes before being told politely to leave.

Having said all that, this movie does stand out from other anti-GMO documentaries I have seen in the past. Not only is it shot really well and contains pretty graphics, but it also gives valid counter-arguments against the anti-GMO movement, and explains why some people are pro-GMO. Yes, Jeremy either dismisses or flat out ignores these counter-arguments and hopes that the audience forgets about them, but the fact that they are there at all shows that Jeremy has a level of credibility far above the likes of Gary Null et al.

From a science point of view, the little of it featured was no different from any other anti-GMO documentary. It’s full of mistakes with the most embarrassing being when Jeremy says that fish that eat GMOs will then themselves become GMOs. There are also several occasions throughout the documentary where Jeremy is flat out lying about GMO research and GM-food safety investigations. As you would expect, there is a fair bit of anti-GMO hysteria, which I think is meant to frighten the viewer but instead had me in stitches. There was one part in particular that had my sides splitting – when Jeremy felt it necessary to dress himself and his two sons in full hazmat gear in order for them to play in his parents’ GM-corn fields. In hindsight, I am not sure what Jeremy’s point was other than to hammer in the fact that his parents’ corn can produce Bacillus thuringiensis delta-endotoxins, which are pesticides. He never goes into detail about this pesticide; nor does he talk about its mode of action and how it is harmless to humans. He also never talks about how these pesticides are used in organic farming – something which he promotes throughout the documentary.

GMO OMG

The movie is also full of familiar faces. Like Vandana Shiva who is the Nicolas Cage of anti-GMO movies, as I believe she has not turned down the chance to be in one yet, and Gilles-Éric Séralini – the lead author of the highly discredited paper “Long term toxicity of a Roundup herbicide and a Roundup-tolerant genetically modified maize”. Jeremy actually travels to France to speak to Séralini and after interview, remarkably mentions faults with the paper. He says that “There may be legitimate criticisms of Séralini’s study. The number of rats and the kind used” however, he unfortunately follows it up with “But shouldn’t his discoveries give us pause”. Jeremy never goes into detail about why Séralini’s study does not make scientists pause for thought. He never mentions that the Sprague-Dawley rats used in the study are known to spontaneously grow tumours. The paper “Spontaneous Tumours in Sprague-Dawley Rats and Swiss Mice” investigates the likelihood of tumour development in these rats, and found that 45% of the rats in its experiment (179 males and 181 females – a larger group than the Séralini paper) developed tumours in an 18-month period (a shorter time than Séralini paper). Jeremy also does not talk about how the paper shows that if you’re male and you drink Round-Up herbicide, you will live longer.

In closing, the movie was very disappointing and I would not recommend you watch it. Yes, it was the first time I have ever seen an anti-GMO documentary raise valid counter points, and yes it does have one of the best movie titles of all time, but this does not make up for the fact that it’s incredibly dull. As I said at the beginning, this movie is mostly padding and very little is dedicated to why you should be against GMOs. What’s worse (and unforgivable) is that the movie does not end with a rap like my all time favourite anti-GMO movie ’Seeds of Death’ but instead we are treated to an oddly sexual dance from some random woman………go figure!

Advertisements
About Myles Power (553 Articles)
My name is Myles Power, and I run the educational YouTube channel, powerm1985. I spend what little free time I have sharing my love of SCIENCE! through home experiments, visiting sites of scientific interest, and angrily ranting at pseudoscience proponents. I am also one of the founding members of the podcast 'The League of Nerds' - which I co-host with James from 'The History of Infection'.

6 Comments on Review of the Movie ‘GMO OMG’

  1. I am surprised you did not make a “Dr. Who” joke with the last image you used in this blog post. When I first saw that image, I expected “Are you my mommy?” to follow it.

    Like

  2. It has just become available for streaming in the US on Netflix. I refused to pay money to see it before, so I finally watched this. It was excruciating to try to refrain from throwing stuff at my TV. Spermicidal corn? He’s worried about artificially stocked fish (which are probably triploid, btw)? FFS. But unlike cranks, I don’t blame one technology for other unrelated problems so I didn’t destroy my TV. I have added this review to Netflix, we’ll see if it ever gets approved.

    A seriously misinformed, misleading, manipulative and anti-science home movie. Sure, his kids are cute–which is nice, because we see so much of them. But it’s completely false that Haiti had been given GMOs, which is only among the first of many falsehoods that pervade this polemic. It continually conflates GMOs with other issues that are not related to GMOs. Cartoons of roaring bollworms are entirely bogus. Scaring his kids over harmless proteins in corn, and dehydrating them while costuming them, should be considered abuse. If you want to believe anything some guy with a camera offers, fine–go ahead. But please at least attempt to find credible sources. Seek out scientists and farmers. This video isn’t a credible source of information. I can’t wait until his seed-loving kid takes his first (non-homeschooled) genetics class. It will be just like the funnel cake.

    Like

  3. Based on the advantages that organic foods offer, many people have made the choice to include them in their diet.
    The aim of this concept is to follow the patterns of past civilizations and inhabitants; land was abandoned when it
    was no longer ecologically useful. However, this
    is a detailed process which requires a systematic understanding of the resources and applying the right
    management approaches. The land on which these herbs are grown should be one that has not
    used chemicals in any form for at least three years.
    Using organic skin care products benefits not only you but other people
    and the environment as well.

    Like

4 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. GMO OMG – Myles Reviews | Myles Power (powerm1985)
  2. GMO OMG – Myles Reviews This is the first in a series of videos… | Scientiflix
  3. OGM = Danger, les preuves scientifiques | La Théière Cosmique
  4. OGM = Danger, les preuves scientifiques | La Théière Cosmique

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s